Laura nodded, jotting notes. “We’ll pull surveillance from the highway cameras. You did the right thing, Mr. Cole.”
But even as she spoke, I couldn’t stop thinking about the baby. The doctor came out later that night and said she would make it—hypothermia, dehydration, but she’d survive. They called her “River,” just a placeholder name. It fit too well.
The next days blurred together. I couldn’t sleep. I kept hearing that cry, kept seeing the crate floating in the dark. The police found tire tracks near the bridge, maybe from the same truck, and a burned-out house twenty miles north. Inside were traces of blood and what looked like baby supplies.
Laura told me they suspected a woman—Angela Moore, twenty-two, missing for two weeks. Neighbors said she’d been pregnant, involved with a man named Derek Hall, who had a record for assault and drug dealing.
It all started fitting together in my mind: Angela, maybe trying to protect the baby from him. Maybe she didn’t survive.
When the detective asked if I’d testify if they caught the man, I didn’t hesitate. “Whatever it takes.”
But it wasn’t over. Two nights later, I got a call from the hospital.
Someone had tried to break into the nursery.
The baby was safe—barely. The intruder fled before security arrived. Witnesses saw a black pickup speeding away.
Laura’s voice was tense when she called me afterward. “Ethan, I think he’s coming back for her.”
And that’s when I made the decision that changed everything.
“I’m not leaving her alone,” I said. “If he wants that baby, he’ll have to go through me.”
The police increased security at St. Mary’s, but Milltown wasn’t exactly a fortress. People here left their doors unlocked, their cars running at the diner. Laura warned me to stay out of it, but I couldn’t.
I started watching the bridge every night, waiting for the black pickup. I didn’t even know why—maybe guilt, maybe instinct. I just needed to understand why.
On the third night, I saw headlights.
The same truck slowed near the riverbank. A man got out—broad shoulders, shaved head, that same dark hoodie. He walked to the edge of the water, looking down at the spot where I’d found the crate.
I stepped out of the shadows. “You looking for something?”
He turned sharply. “Who the hell are you?”
“The guy who saved her.”
For a moment, he froze. Then his jaw tightened. “You should’ve minded your own damn business.”
“Yeah,” I said quietly. “Maybe I should’ve.”
He reached inside his jacket, and I saw the glint of a gun. Before I could move, flashing blue lights cut through the trees. Laura’s voice boomed, “Drop it, Derek!”
He spun around, gun raised. Shots cracked through the night. I hit the ground, covering my head. When the echoes faded, Laura was standing there, gun drawn, breathing hard. Derek lay on the ground, bleeding but alive.
They cuffed him and hauled him away. The next morning, the story was everywhere—“Local mechanic saves abandoned baby, suspect arrested.” But the headlines didn’t capture the weight of it, the quiet horror of what almost happened.
Angela’s body was found days later, near an old cabin in the woods. She’d been dead before Derek ever threw that crate into the river. It turned out she’d written a note—hidden under a loose floorboard in the cabin. Laura let me read a copy.
“If anyone finds my baby, please keep her safe. Her name is Lily.”
When I visited the hospital one last time, Lily was in the nursery, healthy and pink, her tiny fingers gripping my thumb.
“You saved her life,” Laura said softly beside me.
I shook my head. “No. Her mother did.”
Months later, I applied to foster her. It wasn’t easy, but when the day finally came, the nurse handed her to me with a smile.
As I carried her out into the sunlight, I looked back toward the river—calm now, silent—and thought of the night it all began.
Sometimes the world tries to drown what’s innocent. But sometimes, just sometimes, you get there in time.
