They Were All Supposed to Die — But Someone Survived to Tell the Truth

 

At 7:45 a.m. on a quiet street in Moore, Oklahoma, a call came through to emergency services. Three words whispered in the shaking voice of a child. He heard them. Then silence, no name, no address, just the soft clicking sound of the phone going dead. The line was traced. Officers were dispatched.

No one on the team that morning expected to walk into a scene that would ruin their careers, their sleep, and for some, their sanity. Willow Glenn Lane was ordinary. American flags on porches, lawns freshly watered. But that morning, one house stood out. It wasn’t the broken window or the quiet swing creaking in the wind. It was the front door.

Open just an inch, just enough to know something had slipped through. Inside, nothing was broken. No mess, no screams, just stillness. The smell was the first alarm, metallic, faint, but fresh. In the hallway, officers found a trail of something dark soaked into the carpet. No footprints, just a long drag, like something had been pulled.

Tina Martin, age 37, found face down on the floor of the bedroom, dressed for bed. No signs of a struggle. Maggie Martin, age nine, was under the blanket, still tucked in, still holding her stuffed rabbit. Her skull had been caved in. A single blow, no defensive wounds. In the kitchen, breakfast had been started.

Two plates, one untouched, toast in the toaster, juice poured, coffee still warm, but no sign of the husband. No sign of the youngest child until they went downstairs. The basement door had been locked from Tay, he inside. What the first responders saw has never been officially released to the press, but according to leaked reports and the officers who later resigned, Jonathan Martin was found sitting cross-legged on the basement floor, soaked in his wife’s blood.

His six-year-old son, Ben, sat beside him, crying, but physically unharmed. The man was smiling, not with pride, with peace. When officers asked what happened, Jonathan said only this. They weren’t clean. Ben is the only one who was. He then raised his wrists to be cuffed as if he’d been waiting.

 

Before we continue with the story and unspeakable secrets, I want to ask you something important. This channel is not for everyone. Only the bravest souls who dare to confront the darkest chapters of American history. If you made it this far, you’re not like most people. You understand some truths are too horrifying to ignore. no matter how much they disturb us.

So, hit that subscribe button and join our community of true mystery seekers and tell me in the comments what state you are listening from. Are you brave enough to hear a story like this from your own backyard? The child wouldn’t stop shaking. 6-year-old Ben Martin sat wrapped in a police officer’s jacket, his bare feet swinging above the cold lenolium of the station floor. Every time the officer offered him water or asked a question, he turned away.

wouldn’t speak, wouldn’t blink. The boy had blood on his pajamas, not his own, and not a drop of it on his hands. Back at the house, the scene was being locked down. Forensics began their grim work, the bodies of Tina and Maggie, were carefully removed, but the real puzzle, the one that haunted detectives, was the layout of the basement.

There were no weapons found, no signs of a fight, just one wooden chair in the center of the floor. And behind it, drawn crudely on the concrete wall in what appeared to be red crayon or blood, was a symbol, a large circle crossed with uneven lines, almost like a child’s drawing of the sun. Jonathan Martin had written something beneath it. Clean hearts will enter. Unclean ones must be taken back.

It was signed with a single initial. J. Detective Maria Kellerman had been on the force 19 years. She had handled homicides, domestic violence, cult-reated activity, and missing children. But nothing, nothing prepared her for the blank, patient expression on Jonathan’s face. “Why did you do it?” she asked him softly. He didn’t hesitate.

“They were being used,” he said. “The women touched by something wrong, I tried to purify them. Only Ben was spared.” “Because he’s your son?” Jonathan looked up slowly, his eyes dry and unreadable because he listened. That word stuck with Maria. Listened to what? Back in the evidence room, the text found something unexpected.

Dozens of audio tapes labeled by date and kept in a shoe box under Jonathan’s bed. Each one was marked with a title confession Maggie kitchen interference sleeping hours wife Ben’s silence press of most of them were damaged likely erased but a few could be salvaged one tape dated March 18th 1997 began with soft static then Jonathan’s voice I hear it again in the walls in her breathing I think it’s using them to find me I can’t let did it take Ben? Detectives assumed he was suffering from paranoid delusions, but when Ben was later asked about the voice, he only said it was in the drain.

And this is where the town of Moore, Oklahoma began to change. Before the murders, no one talked about the Martins. After the murders, no one would even say their name. The neighbors put their houses up for sale. The school painted over the mural in Maggie’s class.

The bakery Tina used to visit quietly shut down as if the family had never existed. But one thing did remain. Ben Martin, alive, silent, and carrying the story no one wanted to hear. It took nearly 10 years for Ben Martin to speak about what happened. In 2006, at age 16, Ben was living in a foster home under a different surname. He had been bounced between care placements for most of his life.

Described by social workers as withdrawn, compliant, unnaturally quiet. He didn’t speak unless prompted. He barely made eye contact. But one night, he drew something on the wall of his room in pencil. The same symbol from the basement, a circle slashed with radiating lines almost like a primitive sun or eye.

When his foster mother asked what it was, Ben just said, “I saw it in the water. That’s what my dad was listening to.” That’s when the case was reflagged. Dr. Helen Strad was a child trauma specialist in Oklahoma City. She’d worked with victims of abuse, war refugees, and survivors of catastrophic loss. But Ben, even at 16, was like no one she’d met. He didn’t cry.

He didn’t lash out. He spoke slowly, mechanically, as if everything was a memory played back through tape. And the first time he described what happened, he said it like this. We weren’t supposed to go downstairs. But I woke up when I heard mom scream. So I went to the kitchen, but the lights were off and the floor was sticky. Sticky? Dr.

Strad asked gently. Ben nodded. Like jam. She didn’t correct him. He said his father had been up for days, that he stopped going to work, that he kept reading a Bible that didn’t have any words in it. When Ben peaked inside, the pages were all blank, but his father still read aloud. He said something was in the walls, that mom let it in, that Maggie was marked.

Ben told Dr. Strad that his dad had nailed towels over the vents and sealed the bathroom drains with cement. He said it used water to move. Who did? Ben didn’t look at her. He whispered. The one with no eyes. Forensic psychologists dismissed the statement. Mant’s trauma projection. A child’s mind inventing monsters to cope with real life horror.

But there were details Ben gave that had never been released to the public. The placement of the bodies, the color of Maggie’s night gown, the location of the missing kitchen knives, which had never been found. He also mentioned something else.

His mother had tried to leave two nights before it happened, but Jonathan locked all the doors and told them they were sealed in now. Ben said he remembered her crying in the laundry room talking on the phone, but the police records showed no phone service in the Martin home for over 3 weeks. The final thing Ben remembered was the sound of the bathtub running. “It wasn’t normal,” he said. “It didn’t sound like water. It sounded like whispering.” Dr. Straoud asked him what it said.

Ben didn’t answer. He just got up, walked to her office window, and began erasing the condensation with his finger. He drew the symbol again. “That’s the door,” he said. “It lets it in.” And in that moment, Dr. Strad stopped thinking this was just a boy with delusions. because she’d seen that symbol before.

Not in a textbook, not in Ben’s file, but in another unrelated case, one she hadn’t thought about in years. Next, we uncover what Dr. Strad remembered and how another case may be connected. Dr. Helen Strad wasn’t prone to superstition. She’d trained at Cambridge, worked in war zones, and studied psychosis under some of the most brilliant minds in Europe. Her job was to make sense of fractured minds, not entertain ghost stories.

But when Ben Martin drew that symbol, something shifted. A cold clarity settled in her chest. She’d seen it before, exactly once, and it had haunted her for nearly 20 years. In 1987, she was a junior research intern at a psychiatric institution in rural Texas. It wasn’t a place people remembered fondly.

The building itself had been converted from an old sanatorium, and most of its patients were long-term residents, men and women who’d been institutionalized before modern reform laws. One of them was a woman named Dorothy Lanes. Dorothy had been committed at the age of 18 after allegedly drowning her infant son in a motel bathtub. But what made her case stand out wasn’t just the crime. It was her behavior after.

She never showed remorse. She never screamed. She just hummed the same fournote melody over and over, no matter the time of day. Straoud had been assigned to log Dorothy’s daily observations. At first, it felt routine. Then, on the fourth day, she noticed something on the wall beside the bed, a symbol scratched into paint hidden behind a loose tile, the same as the one Ben drew.

Straoud had asked the head psychiatrist about it. He told her it was nonsense. Said some patients fixated on meaningless marks. But a week later, Dorothy was found dead in her room. No suicide note, no signs of struggle. She’d drowned in a locked room with no water source. The staff dismissed it as an embolism, but Straoud always wondered why did her lungs fill with fluid if she hadn’t inhaled anything.

Now nearly two decades later, Ben Martin had drawn the exact same symbol. And when asked where he saw it, he didn’t hesitate. Behind the bathtub. It was already there. Ben never knew Dorothy. He wasn’t even born when she died. But the connection, the deaths, the water, the humming, all pointed towards something older, something no longer confined to just psychiatric records or whispered suspicions.

Straoud retrieved her personal notes from that 1987 case. She still had them in a shoe box. Page after page of Dorothy’s statements. Most were incoherent, but one line stood out, written over and over. The door opens where water lingers. It only needs one listener. She circled that phrase. What if Jonathan Martin had become that listener? What if this wasn’t just psychosis? What if he didn’t imagine something in the drains, but invited it in? Straoud submitted a confidential memorandum to the Oklahoma City Behavioral Unit linking the two cases. It was buried in less than 72 hours. The

response came back in official terms. No verifiable overlap. Recommend no further correspondence on this case. But someone must have read it because that same week her office was broken into. Nothing was taken except her 1987 notes. If Dr. Helen Strad hadn’t gone back to the burned Martin home, none of what followed would have surfaced.

She wasn’t authorized. In fact, she was under direct instruction not to return, especially not alone. The house was condemned, set to be demolished after the arson investigation closed. But something about Ben’s drawing, the symbol, wouldn’t let her go. She needed to see for herself. It was nearly dusk when she arrived.

The two-story suburban house stood like a hollowedout shell, blackened and buckling inward. The fire hadn’t taken everything. But what remained was worse. Walls halfmelted, staircases warped, and inside a lingering smell of burnt plastic and something sweeter. Human. Straoud entered through the rear door. The kitchen was unrecognizable, but the hallway remained intact.

She walked past the charred remnants of picture frames and into the bathroom where Ben claimed to have seen the symbol. The tub was gone. The floor collapsed. But behind the hole in the tiles, something gleamed. Straoud reached in and pulled out a brass ring, not a finger ring, but a structural handle bolted into what looked like a trap door.

It wasn’t part of the house’s original blueprint. She pried it open. Below was a narrow brick well about 3 ft wide, descending into pitch black darkness. The smell that hit her was not of fire. It was something ancient, damp, metallic, like rainwater and rusted bone. Using her phone light, she peered down.

On the bricks every few feet was that same carved symbol. Dozens of them identical. She couldn’t explain it, but in that moment she felt it. The air around her grew heavier. Her chest tightened. Somewhere deep in the well she heard it. A faint humming. Four notes. Just like Dorothy Lane’s. Just like Ben. She backed away and closed the trap.

Back in her car, still shaking, she began researching historical site and balls tied to that shape, she filtered out the usual occult nonsense, instead focusing on local history, municipal records, settler notes, and 19th century state archives. Then she found it. In 1904, just outside Oklahoma City, a settlement church burned to the ground under uncertain circumstances.

No bodies were ever found, but several stone baptismal wells were discovered beneath the ruins. The parish had been excommunicated in 1897 due to a ritualistic deviation from Methodist norms. Among the confiscated relics, a book of hymns, all consisting of four note melodies. On the last page of the book, a handdrawn symbol, identical.

Helen Straoud stared at the scan, heart racing. This wasn’t mental illness. This was inheritance. Whatever had reached Jonathan Martin had reached others before him. And now it was speaking to his son. Next we return to Ben and learn what he saw the night his father changed. Ben hadn’t spoken in weeks. Not since the fire.

Not since he watched his father slit open his mother’s throat in the kitchen while humming a melody no one recognized. But he wasn’t mute. Not exactly. He still whispered, just not to people. Dr. Strad returned to the children’s ward to check on him the morning after discovering the hidden well. She noticed something new.

a metal drain in the corner of the tiled floor, the kind you find in old medical buildings for sanitation. Ben was sitting beside it, knees drawn up, his lips barely moving. She stepped closer. Ben, what are you saying? He didn’t flinch, didn’t blink, just kept whispering softly directly into the drain. four notes again and again like a chant. That same melody. She leaned in closer.

That’s when he stopped and finally looked at her and said, “He’s still singing, but not from here. From under where, Ben?” Ben didn’t answer. He slowly turned the drain’s metal lid with his fingers, not strong enough to lift it, and pointed to the small gap between the grating and the tiles. There, just for a moment, she heard it.

A tap, then another, then something that sounded like muffled humming. From beneath the hospital, Straoud didn’t sleep that night. She pulled every architectural record she could get her hands on for the state-run facility where Ben was being housed. What she found startled her. The building had originally been a state tuberculosis sanatorium built in 1921.

Below the ground level was a network of tunnels and drainage systems, including disused wells, storm cellers, and sealed hydrotherapy rooms that hadn’t been touched in nearly 70 years. And buried in one of the planning sketches, barely visible, was something else. A circle beneath the west wing, marked only with the word ritual pit, sealed 1949.

She printed the sheet and stared at it in disbelief, and no one ever mentioned that in her medical schooling. No one at the hospital talked about it, and yet it had been there the whole time. She returned the next morning to check the drain again. This time the grating had been removed. Ben was nowhere to be found. She sounded the alarm.

Staff searched the hallways, bathrooms, and secure therapy rooms. Nothing until a nurse found the access door to the basement a jar. They followed the old maintenance route, long closed off through rusted stairwells and decaying corridors lit only by emergency bulbs. At the end of one tunnel was a metal utility hatch recently opened.

Below it stairs into darkness. Ben was sitting on the bottom step, calm, silent, and barefoot. When they reached him, he looked up and said something that stopped everyone cold. He stopped singing when I got close because he smelled mom. Ben didn’t resist when they lifted him up the stairs, but he wouldn’t speak either.

He just kept glancing behind them toward the pit at the bottom of the stairwell toward the dark. They took him back to his room and sedated him, but Dr. Straoud stayed behind. She needed to know what was down there. She returned to the stairwell, armed with only a flashlight and a crowbar. The air was colder, damp, smelled like mildew and something else she couldn’t place, like old teeth.

The stairwell ended in a concrete chamber. The walls were covered in black mold. The floor was rotted wood, but in the center, a large square panel had been soared clean out. It looked recent. There were fresh scrape marks, and just beyond that hole was a narrow ring of brick leading straight down. This was it, the ritual pit, and someone had been inside it. She aimed her torch downward.

The shaft was about 15 ft deep. At the bottom, water or at least some dark liquid floating in it. Dozens of papers, photographs, bones, symbols scratched into the walls, visible even through the grime. But it wasn’t just objects. There was something else in the water. Something bigger. She squinted.

It was a figure, hunched, face up, pale. She stumbled back. It was Jonathan Martin’s body or something that looked like him, but it wasn’t decomposed. His skin was pale, but smooth, not bloated, not torn, eyes shut, as if asleep, a peaceful expression, except the corner of his mouth was pulled up just slightly in a smile, like he’d just heard something funny.

Straoud fled up the stairs and reported everything. Police were called. Hazmat teams followed. The recovery took hours. And when the body was pulled up, something else became clear. The throat had not been slit. There was no blood, no signs of trauma. The man was perfectly intact.

So whose body had they found in the kit and that night? And who had they cremated? Ben was awake again that evening, drawing silently in his notebook. Dr. Strad sat beside him. He pushed the notebook toward her, a drawing of the pit. And beside it, not just his father’s body, but a second man. Not a drawing of a dead body. A man standing in the pit, watching, smiling.

Straoud asked. “Who is that, Ben?” he looked down and whispered. He was always under there. Dad just helped him out for a while. She stared at the picture again. The face of the second man wasn’t quite human. Too long, too wide, and where the mouth should have ended, it didn’t. Next, we returned to the house where it all began.

But nothing is where it should be. The recovery team expected rot, dust, blood spatter, something to make sense of the carnage, but when they re-entered the Martin home to begin a full forensic sweep, they found almost nothing. The living room, where the first victim was killed, had already been cleaned. No stains on the carpet.

No drag marks, no signs of a struggle, just a white armchair positioned too perfectly in the center of the room. facing the fireplace. Even stranger, the walls, not just clean, scrubbed, so much so that layers of paint had been stripped back to the plaster in places. One investigator pressed his finger against a faint line beneath a window sill and noticed something.

The white on the wall wasn’t paint. It was lime wash used historically to mask odor and blood. Who had cleaned this? The mother before she died? Or had Jonathan been preparing? In the bathroom, they found a set of surgical tools, old but polished, arranged in a neat row on a white towel. A pair of forceps still had hair stuck to the hinge.

None of it matched any of the family. The DNA tests took weeks, but when they came back, they shocked everyone. The hair belonged to a missing girl from 3 years earlier, a child who’d vanished two streets over. No one had ever connected her case to the Martins. Until now, the town had long whispered that Jonathan Martin had once studied morttery science briefly before becoming a baker.

Now it seemed he hadn’t forgotten a thing. The cellar was worse. Beneath the floorboards, tucked into a hollow between the studs, they found jars sealed tight. Each one filled with alcohol. Inside, body parts, small ones preserved too well for how long they must have been there. A toe, a finger, a tongue. In one, a child’s eye, still intact, floating like a pearl in a dark jar, labeled, dated, no names, just numbers.

Back in his room, Ben was drawing again. Dr. Strad asked him gently. Do you know who those belong to? Ben nodded. They were the bad ones. The bad ones? Dad said they were unclean. God said so. He was saving the good ones. What do you mean saving them? Ben looked up, his voice flat. He said they’d be needed when the house wakes up again. Straoud froze. Wakes up.

Ben pointed to the floor. The walls go to sleep sometimes, but they’ll open again soon. That night, one of the forensic techs, a woman named Carly, locked herself in the bathroom. She was found hours later rocking and whispering, having scratched a single sentence into her arms using a shard of broken mirror. He’s not gone.

He just got in. Deputy Harlon Roads had served in war zones. But nothing unnerved him like the smell under the Martin House. It wasn’t rot, at least not fresh rot. It was older, more sour than putrid, a smell he couldn’t quite place, like wet pennies and spoiled milk, metallic and sweet. He followed it into the cellar, past the broken freezer, past the loose floorboard where the jars had been hidden.

Then he saw it, a trap door set beneath an old rug, almost too perfect, almost staged. He hesitated. behind him. The forensic team began muttering, “You all smell that. Christ, it’s in my clothes now.” When they pried open the trap door, it revealed a set of crumbling wooden steps. Roots had pushed through the ceiling, curling like veins.

The air got colder, wet. They descended in silence, each footfall echoing with a dull, soft thud. Below them, a single corridor carved into Oklahoma clay. No electricity, no ventilation, just dirt walls, hand dug, lined with support beams and carvings. All along the walls, dozens, maybe hundreds of names scratched in with something sharp, fingernails maybe, or old bones.

Some were dates, some had initials, a few were just prayers, but one message repeated every few feet, always the same six words. He feeds the house, the house feeds him. The end of the tunnel opened into a circular room. And there, half buried in the dirt floor, was a large stone, black, obsidian, volcanic glass, too smooth, too perfect. But it hummed, not metaphorically, audibly.

Deputy Roads reached out. Just a finger touched the surface, pulled back instantly. It wasn’t cold or hot. It was alive. “Sir,” one of the team called to him. They’d found something behind the stone. Another jar. Inside, a lock of hair, a milk tooth, and a scrap of paper folded so many times it nearly dissolved when opened.

On it, a handdrawn symbol ruffle is circular, almost like a sun, except the center wasn’t a sun. It was a mouth, teeth, and all. Meanwhile, above ground, Ben had gone silent, stopped drawing, stopped speaking. Dr. Strad noticed something in the boy’s posture. He’d begun to mimic someone or something. He sat with his back straight, his eyes forward.

He refused to look at the windows or the corners of the room. When asked why, he only whispered. He sees through the dirt. Who? Dad said the house had an eye. That’s how it finds who’s next. Back in the tunnel, one of the junior deputies stood too close to the stone. She stepped forward just once and collapsed. Heart attack, seizure, no one could tell, but her lips were moving.

And when they listened closely, she was speaking Latin. The town of Talon Ridge had long forgotten its origins. Most believed it was founded in the late 1800s by cattlemen and churchgoers seeking quiet and faith. But Deputy Roads knew better now. The stone wasn’t just some occult fetish or child’s ghost story. It was part of something older and darker.

When the black slab was unearthed beneath the Martin House, Roads ordered the local archives opened, files untouched for decades, locked drawers with crumbling ledgers, newspaper clippings printed in faded ink on brittle paper, and beneath it all, a church register from 1894. The first few pages were standard births, deaths, weddings.

But then something strange. Every so often the word baptism was crossed out, replaced with the word offering. There were names beside it, children ages 6 to 12, all marked with the same phrase, given to the foundation, witnessed by five. The ink was smeared. Some pages were torn, but the name of the officient remained clear.

Reverend Silas Martin, Jonathan Martin’s greatgrandfather. The Martin family had been part of the town’s bloodline from the beginning, but no one ever talked about them. They owned land, donated to the local church, even helped build the orphanage, always quietly, always just enough to earn trust. But this wasn’t religion. This was ritual. And it went far beyond the martins.

In a dusty old tin, roads found a black and white photo dated 1902. A church congregation outside a long collapsed building. All dressed in black despite the summer date. No smiles. Every child with their hands bound in front of them. At the front, Reverend Silas Martin. One hand on a Bible, the other resting on what looked like a stone altar.

The same stone now beneath the modern Martin home. the same black surface, the same impossible texture. It hadn’t been moved. The house had been built around it. Back at the hospal, Ben was beginning to speak again, but his drawings had changed. Gone with the stick figures. Now he drew eyes, dozens of them, inside floorboards, beneath beds, in the dirt below trees.

He doesn’t sleep, Ben whispered to Dr. Strad. He just waits until the house gets hungry again. Straoud asked who he was. Ben answered with a name no one had taught him. Silas. Later that night, Dr. Strad reviewed old patient files connected to the town. There had been others.

Children who saw things, who heard voices in the ground, who disappeared after sleepwalking. But one report chilled her. A boy in 1974 had spoken a nearly identical phrase. He watches through the dirt, and he too had drawn the same symbol. A circle with a mouthful of teeth, just like Ben. Road sat alone in the archive room that evening, watching the black and white church photo again.

He noticed something he hadn’t before. In the far corner, the shadow of a fifth man, not named, not facing the camera, but where his feet stood, the grass was dead. The discovery came not from an investigator, but from the house itself. One of the demolition crew, a young man named Dylan, had returned alone to the Martin property just after dawn.

His partner was late, and the morning was quiet. Too quiet. Inside the gutted remains of the kitchen wall, Dylan spotted something odd. A portion of drywall that felt wrong. Not newer, but older, hollow. He pried it open and found a box wrapped in thick, rotting fabric. Inside, a journal, bound not in leather, but what looked eerily like tanned animal skin.

The pages were discolored, cracked at the corners, and the handwriting meticulous, steady, clinical. He turned to the first page. There, written in a perfect cursive. If this book is open, the hunger has returned. It feeds through blood, but it sees through the fifth eye. Dylan didn’t understand it, but something told him this was no ordinary diary.

He brought it to Deputy Roads, who immediately took it to Dr. Straoud. Together they opened it carefully, one page at a time. It was written by Reverend Silas Martin, and it chronicled over four decades of offerings. The language was coded, not overt, but spiritual. He spoke of the circle beneath the stone, the voice in the floorboards, and the importance of innocence and silence.

The journal described rituals held on every fifth moon, always involving five members. The others were unnamed, only listed as brother A through brother D, but the fifth, always called the eye. Straoud began to piece it together. The fifth eye wasn’t a person. It was a child. Always a child. One who saw, one who remembered, one who survived.

And for every set of offerings, one child was spared. Not out of mercy, but as witness, as vessel. Ben wasn’t the first. He was the latest. Silas had designed a ritual to continue even after death, something that could pass through bloodlines, through silence, through trauma.

And worst of all, the ritual demanded that the fifth eye return to the house to complete the circle. Straoud looked again at Ben’s newest drawing. This one was different. It was a map, not of the house, but beneath it, crawl spaces, secret rooms, trap doors, and at the center, a black shape circled in red. Next to it, the words, “It’s not sleeping.” She asked Ben who told him about the map. He didn’t speak.

He only looked toward the wall and smiled. Next, we uncover what lies beneath the foundation and why the Martins were never allowed to move away. The floor of the Martin home had always creaked in strange places, even when it was newly built. Locals once blamed it on bad construction or Oklahoma’s shifting ground.

But after the journal was discovered, the attention turned downward. Ben’s map showed something the blueprints never had. a trap door under the hallway rug. Deputy Roads and Dr. Straoud along with two state officials returned to the home. The rug was long gone, but the wooden panel beneath it was unmistakable. Unlike the rest of the floor, this panel had nails that had been burned black.

When pried open, they released a smell like wet coins and dead air. They descended with gloves, flashlights, and a GoPro. The crawl space was dry, silent, untouched by time. But 10 ft in, the floor gave way to something deeper, a hollowedout pit, man-made.

There were markings on the walls, symbols carved into stone similar to those in Ben’s drawings, and at the center, laid in a circle of dried blood and ash, four decayed bodies. They weren’t recent. Straoud guessed they’d been buried at least 30, 40 years ago, far earlier than the recent murders, and they had all been positioned the same way. Arms crossed, eyes gouged, mouths stitched shut.

Near them, scraps of old cloth, remnants of robes or ceremonial garments, had been preserved in the still dry earth. Alongside them, a wooden bowl cracked in half with what looked like teeth embedded in its rim. One more thing, there were spaces for five. One body was missing. The implications were horrifying. The Martins didn’t start the ritual. They inherited it.

Each generation passing it forward, cleansing, sacrificing, hiding. Silas had simply refined it, making it cleaner, more spiritual, easier to conceal. He didn’t invent the evil. He was raised by it. Then came the deeper question. Who was the missing body who had been part of the orinal circle and escaped burial? Was it Silas or worse? Someone still alive? Someone who made sure the fifth body remained available for the next cycle.

As they emerged from the pit, roads spotted something else, wedged into the dirt near the fifth grave. A child’s shoe, clean, preserved, as if it had never decayed. Inside it, folded neatly, was a slip of paper. It read, “He watches through their eyes. He waits until they forget.” Ben had drawn that symbol, too. Only he didn’t call it a symbol. He called it the mouth in the ground.

The question haunted every investigator, every forensic tech, and every reader of Ben’s journal. Who was the missing fifth body? To find out, Deputy Roads turned to the oldest surviving records of the land itself. Before the house was built in 1962 by Paul and Ruth Martin before the farmhouse, before the clearing, the land had belonged to an unincorporated religious commune, active from 1948 to 1955.

There were no tax filings, no death certificates, and no clear leadership. They were known by locals only as the circle of providence. Most people assumed they were missionaries or a prayer group, but a surviving land deed named five trustees. All male, all unrelated by blood, but all with ScotsIrish Appalachian surnames.

One of them, Gideon Martin, Silus’s grandfather. An archived fire report from 1955 revealed that their original chapel, a crude wooden structure near the creek, burned to the ground in late summer. The cause unclear, but the report notes a chilling line scrolled in chalk across the ruined threshold. One broke the seal, the rest must feed.

Soon after the fire, four of the five men disappeared. No records, no burials. Only Gideon remained. And two months later he bought the land again in his own name this time and began construction on what would become the Martin home. The exact center of the home sat at top the burned chapel site.

Ben’s journal contained pages that looked out of place. Written in a much older hand. They were brittle, inked in faded brown with phrases like, “The mouth below is never sated. Only the fifth shall walk above.” He watches through their eyes, waits until the vessel is ready. The writing matched samples of Gideonss from state records. He had kept the pages, probably passed down after the fire, and Silas had given them to Ben without explanation.

What this meant was undeniable. The Martin murders were not a sudden tragedy. They were the continuation of an old pact passed down from men who believed in feeding something beneath the land. Something they called providence. Only one had tried to walk away. He never reappeared. And every generation since. Someone always died.

Someone was always spared. But why Ben? Why was he the one they left behind? Back in the basement, roads laid out the evidence. Four bodies in the pit, a fifth space left open, a child’s shoe preserved, and the land’s history pointing toward a ritualistic cycle. Ben’s survival wasn’t an accident. It was a choice. Someone had chosen him, just like someone had chosen Silas once years ago.

The horror wasn’t just in what they did. It was in how long they’d been doing it. It was summer 1979. Silus Martin had just turned 19. By then he was already a hardened young man, sharpeyed, strong willed, and cold in a way no child should have been. But he was also curious. And that curiosity, Ruth used to say, would be the ruin of him.

He began to dig, not because he suspected anything, but because the basement had begun to smell. Not like mold, something sharper, metallic, like old coins and rot. It started after a thunderstorm. Silas had been in the root cellar taking inventory for his father when he heard something behind the wall. A scraping, then a knock, then silence. At first, he thought it was a rat.

Maybe a raccoon. But then it spoke. I told them not to finish it. They didn’t listen. You still can. Silus pried open the wall. Behind the loose bricks was an earththen tunnel. Not tall enough to stand in, but long enough to disappear into shadow. He crawled. For 30 ft. He moved through mud, stones, and a smell that grew thicker the deeper he went.

And then suddenly a chamber carved by hand, reinforced with wooden beams older than the house. And there, lying in the dirt, was a man. His hair had thinned to wisps. His teeth were brown and shattered. But his eyes, they were Gideon’s eyes. It was Caleb, one of the original five, the one who had run. He hadn’t escaped.

He had been buried, or perhaps buried himself, in the soil beneath the chapel ruins. Silas didn’t run. He sat with the man for hours. He listened. Caleb told him everything about the pact, the thing beneath the ground, the price for protection. We thought it would keep us safe. It did for a while, but we never stopped paying.

One by one, it took us until I was the only one left. And now you’ve built a house on its back. Silus asked him why he stayed. Why not just run? Caleb smiled or tried to. What was left of his lips cracked open and like paper. Because it speaks. Because I hear it in my sleep. And if I leave, it follows. He held something out to Silas.

A box wrapped in leather, stitched shut with twine made of hair. Silas took it. When you know what’s inside, you’ll understand why you must never have a son. Years later, that same box would be found among Silus’s possessions. Deputy Roads didn’t open it at first, but he would.

And when he did, the story would shift again. Because what was inside shouldn’t exist. Not in 1986. Not in 1955. Not anywhere. That night in 1979, Silas sealed the tunnel behind him. He told no one, not even Ruth. But he began preparing. He knew now what the house had been built on. He knew why his family kept surviving while others vanished.

And he knew that one day he’d have to offer something back. Silas didn’t open the box for 5 years. He kept it buried beneath the floorboards of his room, hidden in a shoe box beneath folded towels and a Gideon family Bible that hadn’t been touched since the late60s. Ruth once asked him what he was hiding. He said, “A part of someone?” She never asked again.

But in 1984, 2 years before the police ever came near the Martin House, something changed. A child from the next county, 7-year-old Jacob Deetsz, disappeared on his way to school. The fourth child in 2 years. No bodies, no suspects, no ransom notes, just a trail of old stories. whispers from folks on the edge of town who spoke of a shadow with hands, children led by music, and a name that had begun to circulate again. Martin Hollow.

Silas had grown into a man by then, still living on the farm, still quiet, still watching. But now he opened the box. Inside were strands of hair, human, brittle, and each bound with parchment tags, aged and yellow. Each tag bore a name, a date, and what looked like a small carved symbol, not English, not anything readable. There were 14 bundles. Silas read the names.

He knew seven of them. They weren’t from Martin Hollow. They were from Wilks County, Green, Ash, the same counties where those missing children were being reported. now. He took the box to the Wilks County Records Office, didn’t speak, just placed it on the desk of the receptionist and left. That same week, Deputy Sheriff Sarah Manning, then knew to the force, was handed the file.

What she read in those tags would eventually lead her to reopen the Martin family history. But she didn’t believe in folklore. She believed in patterns. And these names, they weren’t just victims. They were all tied to families who had once lived in or near the original Gideon tract, land that was supposed to have been sold off after the church burned in 1921.