Queen Elizabeth II reportedly expressed concerns about Kate Middleton early in her relationship with Prince William, primarily due to Kate’s lack of a defined career path. According to royal expert Katie Nicholl, the Queen believed Kate needed a “proper job” to prepare for her potential role as William’s consort. This perspective stemmed from the Queen’s view that Kate should be settled in a stable career before an engagement, ensuring she had an identity and purpose independent of the royal family. Sources suggest the Queen shared these thoughts with friends, describing Kate as a “problem” because she wanted William to delay proposing until Kate had established herself professionally.

At the time, Kate had worked briefly for her family’s business, Party Pieces, and as a part-time accessories buyer for Jigsaw, but these roles were not seen as substantial enough by the Queen, who valued a strong work ethic and public service. Posts on X also reflect this sentiment, noting the Queen’s reservations about Kate’s lack of a professional portfolio and her initial perception of Kate as potentially “lazy.”

Over time, Kate’s dedication to royal duties and her charitable work, particularly in early childhood care, shifted perceptions. Her close relationship with the Queen developed, with the monarch supporting Kate during public engagements and appreciating her contributions to the royal family.